return to Words & Music Shop main page return to
ML Hart Home

AJRJTJIJSJTJJJPJRJOJFJIJLJE

TOP
Enrico Caruso - the Tenor of the Century



 

November 17, 1898
Teatro Lirico, Milano
world premiere of Fedora

"The applause was not mere hand clapping, but it seemed to be explosions of passion. The cheers became overwhelming. Caruso gave an encore, as soon as I, surprised by that insistent, intoxicating storm, was able to calm down and start conducting again. The delirium was ecstatic and then there was a second encore and then another. The third act was a crescendo of enthusiasm... Fedora had been consecrated with the new star. Caruso's voice had conquered everyone's heart."
Umberto Giordano,
composer of Fedora
the performance was conducted
by the composer, who recalls the
response to Amor ti vieta


Caruso as Samson

“What does it take? A big chest, a big mouth, 90% memory, 10% intelligence, and something in the heart.”

- Enrico Caruso

 

ENRICO CARUSO
1873 - 1921

The Tenor of the Century - indeed, for many music lovers, Enrico Caruso is the quintessential Italian tenor of all time.

A perfect reflection of the age of verismo in opera, Caruso was the embodiment of the modern tenor sound, that big, passionate, macho-masculine voice. Until Caruso, most tenors inhabited a universe all their own (and admittedly, they still do). But before Caruso, it was with an elegant but effete, somewhat-removed sound; Jean de Reszke, toast of the town until Caruso arrived on the scene, was the le beau idéal.

Born in Naples in 1873 to a working class family, young Errico was involved in music from his childhood, singing in church. His first voice teacher told him he would never amount to anything as a singer. But he made his professional debut at age 21 in two performances - probably the only two, says Michael Scott - of Morelli's Amico Francesco, performances that lacked not only refinement but accurate top notes. By training and hard work, Caruso blended a superb natural voice with his passionate, headstrong personality, and three years later, stunned the opera world singing the lead in the world premiere of Giordano's Fedora. [review, at left]  Here was a tenor who could thrill an audience beyond anything they'd experienced before.

For his first engagement as Rodolfo in La Bohème, the condition of his contract was that the young tenor must get approval from the composer. After Caruso had sung a few phrases, Puccini leapt up from the piano crying "Who sent you to me? God himself?!" He got the job.

Enrico Caruso occupied the top of the opera world for the next 23 years, performing in London, Milan, Russia and South America. When he made his debut at New York's Metropolitan Opera in 1903, he found his artistic home. He sang there every winter in a total of 37 different operas, establishing new guidelines for fees paid to opera singers, earning huge amounts of money... and giving it away. He spent almsot $9,000 each season at the Met, buying advance tickets, handing them out to friends old and new. And each Christmas, a truck would draw up at the stage door of the Met bearing a present for every single employee in the house. After Caruso's death it was found that more than 120 people were on his informal payroll, people he supported.

He was a popular, likeable fellow, making it easy for those outside of opera circles to embrace him, too - and through his records, he was known all over the world, to regular opera-goers as well as the man in the street. In some views, it was Caruso who made the recording industry. Caruso's drawing of himself with the recording apparatus

The recordings were made throughout his entire career and include arias, popular Italian songs, and during World War I, a rally-round-the-flag rendition (in charmingly broken English) of Over There - which was yet another best seller. He also frequently sang for war charities with tenor John McCormack and popular artists Al Jolson and George M. Cohan.

While Caruso's emotional intensity created magical performances, he was much more than loud bluster and razzle-dazzle. Contributing to his long productive career was his solid vocal technique, grounded, though not locked, in the "old-style" singing principles of bel canto, which enabled him to spin out delicate phrases, contrasting with the big masculine sound of his voice - he knew when to use what - and he retained this ability as he got older. He was the perfect bridge between generations of operatic style - many of his direct contemporaries were able to forge new audiences too, but none so effectively as Caruso. Those who came after him tended to imitate his mannerisms without mastering the technical control.

Caruso's signature roles were those of the romantic married to the verismo - Cavaradossi in Tosca and Canio in Pagliacci. The verismo opera style was at its peak during Caruso's prime, and he created many roles for living composers, since opera - and new opera - was a vibrant, breathing art form during the first half of Caruso's career. As opera changed and adapted (as it has for 400 years) the second half of his career was spent primarily with revivals. Since the disappearance of the castrati more than a century before Caruso's time, the superstars of the opera world were women - the sopranos, prime donne - and all the men were bystanders, no matter how admired they might be. Caruso changed all that, his name known far beyond the small circle of the opera world.

 


Caruso as Eléazar in "La Juive"
Enrico Caruso took on his final role in 1920: Eléazar in La Juive for opening night at the Met. His portrayal was a carefully studied portrait that would have been inconceivable in the young tenor at his debut in 1903. To capture the halting steps described in the orchestra when the terrified Eléazar appears before the Inquisition, Caruso deliberately wore a pair of shoes that fit badly, forcing him into an awkward and clumsy walk appropriate for the old man.

Caruso was at the height of his fame - and he was already seriously ill with pleurisy.

On 11 December, while singing in L'Elisir d'Amore, he was spitting blood with every phrase - management finally stepped in and suspended the performance. Two days later, he sang a "brilliant" Forza; three weeks after that, an effortful Eléazar, his 863rd performance at the Met.

Photographer Herman Mishkin went to Caruso's dressing room at intermission and made the portraits of the great tenor on the last night he would ever sing. He sailed home to Naples to rest and recover - but there would be no recovery. Nine months later he died at the age of 48. Caruso had achieved such fame and honour throughout the world that the King of Italy ordered the Basilica di San Francesco di Paola, normally reserved for royal occasions, to be used for the funeral service. His passing was seen as monumental, a grievous loss to music... but in so many ways, he lives on.

Enrico Caruso in his dressing room, on the night of his final performance.



Caruso as the Duke in "Rigoletto"

 

Caruso as Canio in "Pagliacci"



Tenor John McCormack heard Caruso in La Bohème at Covent Garden in 1904. Thirty years later, he wrote: "...that voice still rings in my ears, the memory of it will never die."

Caruso's sound was completely unique - audiences had never experienced anything like it before, nor has anyone since. No tenor (and as a group, they're not exactly known for their modesty) has ever claimed to be his equal. He sang hundreds of performances, dozens of different roles, and recorded more than 260 titles, showing the range of his expressive voice from the lyrical quality of Donizetti to the dramatic weight of the later Verdi operas.

While nearly every tenor's voice takes on differing characteristics as he ages, especially in timbre, Caruso always had a baritonal underpinning to his voice, giving it darkness and power. But a favorite story goes like this: during a performance of La Bohème, the basso, Andreas DeSegurola, lost his voice just before his Act IV aria. Standing close by but facing upstage, Caruso sang Vecchia zimarra for him, while DeSegurola mouthed the words and acted through the aria. Caruso enjoyed it so much, he made a recording of it shortly afterwards.

Fellow tenor (and some say, successor) Beniamino Gigli wrote:

"I wonder what would have become of me if, like him, I had been born in a city slum; for I did not have the gifts of personality that enabled Caruso to create life and warmth around him wherever he went."

Enrico Caruso leaves us his recordings, the written accounts of his performances, and the memory of an unparalleled career, one that altered the history of opera. He remains the ultimate model for every aspiring opera singer, and his "something in the heart" keeps him forever in ours.

 


"He sang Celeste Aida so brilliantly that the applause stopped the show... his Radames reached such heights that those lucky enough to have been present will remember the occasion for the rest of their lives. ... What happened at the end of this [final] duet [with Emmy Destinn] was not merely applause, but an uproar, a cry of jubilation. The audience clapped, yelled and stamped their feet... In the course of many years I witnessed many triumphant Caruso nights but none quite like that Aida."

- Emil Ledner, Caruso's German manager, Berlin, October 25, 1907

Enrico Caruso as Radames

 


TOP OF PAGE      |    BIO    |      BOOKS     |    EXPLORE MORE   
FIRST RECORDING SESSION     |    SELECTED RECORDINGS

THREE LEGENDARY TENORS
Caruso / Gigli / Björling
order THREE LEGENDARY TENORS
presented by tenor & author Nigel Douglas
 
click on the cover to order directly
 

"About this time [Feburary 1902] Caruso was becoming involved in something which at the start hardly anybody took seriously but which was to bring him his greatest rewards in fame as well as money. He had just participated in another world premiere, Germania, when F.W. Gaisberg of the Gramophone and Typewriter Company arrived in Milan and set up shop in the Grand Hotel, directly above the suite where Verdi had died the year before. The proposition relayed to London was for ten arias, to be done in a single afternoon, at a fee of one hundred pounds for the lot - about fifty dollars a record. London cabled back, "Fee exorbitant. Forbid you to record."

"Partly because he was too embarrassed to go back to Caruso with such an answer, Gaisberg took matters in his own hands and ordered the recording session to proceed. Caruso sauntered in, tossed off his ten numbers in two hours - without blemish, Gaisberg says in his biography - and was on his way.

"The precious waxes were rushed to Hanover; the finished products reached London in time for release to coincide with Caruso's Covent Garden debut - they were a sensation. The Victor Talking Machine Company took over the G. and T. masters and Caruso's career, too. His first records in this country were made less than three months after his Metropolitan debut, his last within a year of his death."

from OPERA ANECDOTES, as told by Ethan Mordden

[see discussion of monetary conversion of the fee]

 

BOOKS
order ENRICO CARUSO: MY FATHER, MY FAMILY   ENRICO CARUSO: MY FATHER AND MY FAMILY
by Enrico Caruso Jr. and Andrew Farkas

The best of the biographies, exhaustively researched and accurate in detail where many of the other books are not. Caruso's common-law marriage to Ada Giachetti is thoroughly documented here, again unlike the other biographies. Enrico Jr. wrote much of the story with his brother, but it was put aside after Rodolfo's death. Many years later, Andrew Farkas helped craft it all into book form.
With chronology of Caruso's performances and list of his repertoire by Thomas G. Kaufman, discographies by William R. Moran and Richard Koprowsky, and bibliography by Opritsa Popa.

order OPERA ANECDOTES    

ENRICO CARUSO - HIS LIFE AND DEATH
by Dorothy Caruso

This is the basis for the film The Great Caruso, starring Mario Lanza. The book bears little resemblance to reality (nor does the film), and is a sanitized version of what Caruso's widow wanted the world to know. They were married for about three years at the end of his life, long after his character and career had been forged.


THE GREAT CARUSO
by Michael Scott

Gives a unique understanding of Caruso as an artist by quoting extensively from contemporary reviews, newspaper articles, and private diaries. Scott's musical analysis is keen here, as it is in the two-volume work The Record of Singing. With chronology by Thomas G. Kaufman; discography by John R. Bolig
Excellent biography - highly recommended.

     
TOP OF PAGE      |    BIO    |      BOOKS     |    EXPLORE MORE   
FIRST RECORDING SESSION     |    SELECTED RECORDINGS

 

 

O
SELECTED RECORDINGS FEATURING ENRICO CARUSO:

There are many CDs available of Enrico Caruso's recordings. But the recording company of Prima Voce has had significantly greater success than most others in transferring material from the early part of the century to the CD format.
Learn about their techniques.

 

caruso_voce.jpg (5585 bytes)

CARUSO

20 arias, from Verdi (Aida, Rigoletto, Forza, Ballo) and Puccini (Tosca) to Donizetti (from L'Elisir d'Amore and Don Sebastiano); also Meyerbeer, Gomes, Leoncavallo and Massenet. His final role, Eléazar in La Juive, is represented here as well.
There's also a Volume 2 available.

caruso_early.jpg (5393 bytes) The Early Recordings

2 CDs
A huge range of music, mostly arias. The first disc is all Caruso; the second is all his contemporaries.

caruso_ensemb.jpg (6267 bytes) Caruso in Ensemble

Recordings from 1906-1918 with Farrar, Scotti, Journet, Alda, others. From Forza, Butterfly, the final duet from Aida, Il Trovatore, and the quartet from Rigoletto.

caruso_song.jpg (5312 bytes) Caruso in Song

Popular songs in Italian and English, including La Danza, O Sole Mio, Ombra Mai Fu, Because, and Over There.

caruso_song2.jpg (4615 bytes) Caruso in Song, Vol. 2

More Neopolitan songs, including Core 'ngrato, 'A vuccella, and Serenata.

click on any album cover to order directly

x
THE COMPLETE RECORDINGS    -    12 CDs
order CARUSO - THE COMPLETE RECORDINGS The Italian tenor Enrico Caruso holds a unique place in musical history... The Naxos Historical Caruso edition constitutes the complete cycle of all Caruso's recordings issued in chronological order. In addition, the transfers have been immaculately undertaken by top sound engineer Ward Marston, unrivalled for his knowledge of the specialized world of acoustic opera recordings, and his rare ability to retrieve all of the music lying in the grooves of the original recordings.  "...One of the most significant recording industry events of the decade."        - Fanfare Magazine
also available individually - see pictures of Volumes 1 and 3, below:
order VOLUME 1 of THE COMPLETE RECORDINGS order VOLUME 3 of THE COMPLETE RECORDINGS
 
click on any album cover to order directly
3 LEGENDARY TENORS

Caruso / Gigli / McCormack
Not the same 3 as in Nigel Douglas' film, above, but 2 out of 3 ain't bad... and they're singing the entire piece, unlike the clips heard on the DVD. About an equal blend of arias and songs.

caruso_3.jpg (6087 bytes)
COVENT GARDEN
AN EARLY HISTORY ON RECORD

Caruso sings Questa o quello, and there are recordings of his leading ladies: Melba, Tetrazzini, Turner, Supervia, Destinn. The men, too: Chaliapin, Tibbett, Tauber and Gigli. More, besides. Fascinating journey back in time - wonderful CD.
caruso_garden.jpg (6310 bytes)
CARUSO & FRIENDS

The "friends" are Caruso's contemporaries and those who followed - the album consists of one of his recordings (the major tenor arias) followed by the same aria recorded by one of the others. Nice way to learn about the differences in the voices.
caruso_friend.jpg (5513 bytes)
 


TOP OF PAGE      |    BIO    |      BOOKS     |    EXPLORE MORE   
FIRST RECORDING SESSION     |    SELECTED RECORDINGS

 

 


MORE ABOUT ENRICO CARUSO:

The Enrico Caruso Page

The Enrico Caruso Museum of America

Associazione Museo Enrico Caruso

Grandi Tenori - Enrico Caruso

The Voice of Caruso - La Scena Musicale

Metropolitan Opera History: Caruso and "La Juive"

more about PRIMA VOCE

ML Hart Website:
PASSION & GLORY AT THE OPERA - The Tenor Book

 


 

£100 GBP in 1902 - how to figure what it might mean in today's money, and specifically in today's dollars? Most historical conversions are based on a Consumer Price Index [Retail Price Index in Great Britain].

If you take Morddern's number of $50/record x 10 records = $500, and use the CPI level, adjusting for inflation, you get an equivalent of about $12,500 (in 2005 USD). Not bad for 2 hours' work. But the CPI has to do with the price of potatoes and paper clips, and whether in urban or rural settings, those have little to do with what a singing artist might command - even one only 29-years old who, at the time of the Milan recording session, had yet to appear in either London or the United States. Data-gathering has changed over the course of a century, too, which complicates the sequence of conversions even further.

However, if you blend an Average Earnings index with a Per Capita GDP index [from the Officer tables, below] and then convert historical pounds to dollars, you come up with a slightly more realistic approximation for "wages earned" - (whether you start with the total fee in pounds or the dollar amount per record, it ends up in the same vicinity) - and it's equal to about $56,100 (in 2004 USD). Even better for 2 hours' work. And wildly profitable for both The Grammophone Company - which sold the first 10 records for a profit of £15,000 - and for Caruso, who earned about $3 million in royalties over his lifetime.

Of course, finances are not exactly my forté, so I could've done the calculations backwards, for all I know!  But you get the idea. See links, below.    - ML Hart

 

return to Words & Music Main Page

return to Words & Music - Tenors

questions /
comments
e-mail ML Hart
send e-mail

 

 

 

all reviews by ML Hart except as otherwise noted
original content ©2005 ML Hart, graphics © copyright 1999 ML Hart and images © copyright 1999 ML Hart except CD covers or where noted

black & white photograph of Enrico Caruso and his white piano, specially made for him - photographer unknown

portraits of Caruso as Samson and Eléazar by the great Herman Mishkin
other photographs in costume by unknown photographers, though very likely Mishkin again

story about bying advance tickets to the Met performances told by Francis Robinson in CARUSO - His Life in Pictures

drawing of Caruso with the recording apparatus - by Enrico Caruso

historical monetary conversion tables (British Pounds) and an explanation
of the various indices used, provided by Lawrence H. Officer,
"What Is Its Relative Value in UK Pounds?" Economic History Services, October 30 2004

monetary conversion formula (US Dollars) provided by Professor Robert Sahr of the
Oregon State University Political Science Department,
adusted for inflation by using a calculator on the Columbia Journalism Review website

profitability of the records - those numbers from David Sarnoff's online history of The Victor Talking Machine Company

back to opera... Sandy Steiglitz keeps a website overflowing with singer photographs, many of them
from the vintage era I so admire -
my thanks to her for all the work she does there

finally, as with all these Artist Profile pages, I find myself immensely grateful for Michael Scott's A Record of Singing, a massive two-volume work. It has helped me understand far more about the technical aspects of singing than I ever believed I could. Jump to a brief review of the books on the More Great 20th Century Tenors page, or if you're hooked on generations past, as I am, explore more for yourself.


no part of this page, site, or any components may be borrowed, downloaded, acquired, or otherwise
used by any person(s) without the express written consent of ML Hart
- all rights reserved -


what is copyright all about?