return to Words & Music Shop main page return to
ML Hart Home

AJRJTJIJSJTJJJPJRJOJFJIJLJE

top
Feodor Chaliapin as a young man

Feodor Chaliapin in his prime

 

 

"Only now do I realise that I never had, up to this time, any but poor devils."

- Arrigo Boito

 

Feodor Chaliapin in "Don Quichotte"

 

Feodor Chaliapin as Holofernes in "Judith" by Valentin Serov

"It is impossible to describe how he sang. He sang as Tolstoy wrote."

- Sergei Rachmaninov


Feodor Chaliapin as Tonio in "Pagliacci" - he sang certain of the baritone roles, as always, making them his own.

Feodor Chaliapin as the Viking Merchant in Rimsky-Korsakov's "Sadko"

 

 

Feodor Chaliapin as Boris Godounov


Feodor Chaliapin as Ivan the Terrible in Rimsky-Korsakov's "The Maid of Pskov"

 

 

"It took the audience but a brief moment to see that an unusual artist was before them, and when his voice rang out the ear emphasized the impression of the eye."

- The New York Herald



Feodor Chaliapin as Mephistofeles in "Faust" - a role he always believed he failed to capture.

FEODOR CHALIAPIN
1873-1938

The most influential opera singer ever was an imposing figure of a man with a dark-timbred basso-cantante voice. Feodor Chaliapin, born the same year as Enrico Caruso (who also played a crucial part in changing the art form), was the first Russian singer to establish a great international career, and his reputation stretches across the decades. His impact in making the drama and the acting in opera equal with the music, and in transforming the basso from supporting player to protagonist, is still felt today - partly by way of the wealth of written and recorded material he left us.

With only four years of formal schooling, Chaliapin fled a poverty-stricken and abusive home at age 17, and joined a traveling theatre company. In terms of music, the story is that he was self-taught - but at age 19, he met Dmitri Uzatov, a retired tenor. Himself a second-generation pupil of the legendary teacher Manuel García, Uzatov gave Chaliapin classic vocal technique, grounded in the singing expression of earlier centuries.

His career began at the Tiflis (later Tbilisi) Opera, the Mariinsky Theater (later known as the Kirov) and especially at Moscow Private Opera, where Chaliapin helped bring works by Russian composers to the stage. By the age of 26 when he joined the Bolshoi, he was already the foremost opera singer in Russia. At 29 - singing his first engagement abroad and his first opera in Italian - he shared the stage at La Scala with Enrico Caruso in Arrigo Boito's Mefistofele, redefining the title role for the composer, and becoming the foremost bass singing in Europe. In 1907 Chaliapin made his Metropolitan Opera debut in that same role and also played Don Basilio [see reviews, below]. For Opéra Monte Carlo in 1910 he created the title role in Massenet's Don Quichotte (a role written specifically for him) and later made a film of the opera. But it was not until Diaghilev brought Boris Godunov and a season of Russian opera to Paris in 1908 and then to London in 1913-14, that Chaliapin was fully acclaimed as the great artist he was. That second season, he sang four performances in each of four Russian operas in a two-month time span, to the applause of audiences, critics - and himself. Chaliapin wrote, rather delightedly, in a letter: "...From good luck, I am stringing here my performances like pearls, one next to another. Which one is better, I cannot say."

After the revolution Chaliapin remained in Russia for a time, but eventually found the rigidity of the Communist regime as distasteful as the Romanov, and he subsequently emigrated. He was denounced as an "anti-revolutionary" and deprived of all his Russian property and titles. He died in Paris, an exile, in 1938.


But back in the winter of 1907-08, at the age of 34, Chaliapin arrived in New York and set the city alight. Earning a staggering $1,600 a performance [more than $33,000 in 2005 dollars], he created a furore in the operatic world [reviews, below!] and redefined the notion of dramatic performance by bringing a fiercely committed intelligence to his roles and immersing himself in them fully - bodily and vocally. Remember that a basso, before Chaliapin, was neither an artist nor a star.

He did not much care for the Americans' greedy pursuit of money and their general ignorance of art, though the audiences embraced him. Many critics seemed unable to understand his work on stage, and there is some evidence that the Metropolitan Opera management provided him with translations of only the hostile reviews, presumably as a cost-saving measure. In his splendid biography of Chaliapin, Victor Borovsky quotes a reference that an American critic of the time thought that "the initiative was coming from the all-powerful director of the Metropolitan Opera, Heinrich Conried, 'who had no desire to retain in his company a bass who demanded sixteen hundred dollars a night, a high salary for a soprano or a tenor.'"  Needless to say, the Metropolitan Opera History web page leaves this part out. Chaliapin was all too glad to see the end of his American tour.

Chaliapin was known for his exuberance in life, as well as on the stage.

"The great Russian basso was a friend of the family and a frequent visitor in our home. Not that we children got to see too much of him. Chaliapin had a towering reputation as a story-teller – he was probably the greatest raconteur in all of Russia. The trouble was that most of his stories were of the sort that are not supposed to be fit for the ears of children. And so, as soon as dinner was over, my brother and I were sent away to our quarters, and all we heard of Chaliapin’s stories were the gales of roaring laughter that emanated from the living room."

- Boris Goldovsky, vocal coach / director


Considered the greatest dramatic singer of his day, Chaliapin was one of the first singers to apply psychological techniques to operatic acting. The way the character stands, the way he moves, how he turns, what he would wear, the rhythm of his speech translated into music - all was based on that character's thoughts and emotions at the time, rather than on any kind of stand-and-sing operatic convention. His insistence that every aspect of a performance - production and lighting details, not just the music or the words - should be dedicated to the dramatic and psychological essence of the work being performed was, in those days, nothing short of revolutionary.

"The opera singer has to contend not with one, but with three arts at once - vocal, musical and theatrical. In this reside both the difficulty and the advantages of his creative work.... These three arts the singer must fuse into one, and direct it to a common aim."

- Constantin Stanislavskiy
"My Life in Art and The Actor's Workshop" 1936

That same insistence could sometimes make working with him a contentious proposition, to put it mildly - he didn't suffer fools gladly. But all his focus on detail was less for his ego and more for the complete presentation of the work; Chaliapin sometimes produced (stage directed) the operas he performed in, and he always designed his own makeup and wigs to create the look he wanted. Note this reaction, from the well-respected critic Vladimir Vasilievich Stasov, after seeing a performance of Rimsky-Korsakov's Sadko:

"...the Viking himself suddenly appears, looking as if his bones had been hacked from the cliffs. There he stands, immense... His gigantic voice, the prodigious eloquence of his singing, the herculean movements of his body and arms, as if a statue had been given life and movement, the look under his thick frowning brow: all this was so new, so powerfully and deeply real that I could not help asking myself, completely stunned, 'But who is this, who is it? What actor? Where can one find people like that in Moscow? What amazing people!' And suddenly in the interval I found out that it was none other than Chaliapin."


Chaliapin's appearances on the opera stage introduced some decisive changes in the opera-performance status quo. A perfectionist with regard to his makeup, costumes, dramatic and musical preparation, he was very attentive to the staging of the shows he was in. In developing his performance style, he studied actors and painters as well as singers. He was almost more actor than singer in his approach to the characters he portrayed, and he always used his body as much as his face or his voice. And at more than six feet tall, he had a lot of body to work with; and would really use the differences between his height and that of other singers rather than trying to disguise it. In "Barbiere," Alessandro Bonci and Chaliapin, drawn by Enrico Caruso

As mesmerizing an actor as he was, we remember him equally for the grace and power of his singing. For Chaliapin, moving away from the era of bel canto as he was, beautiful singing was not merely elegant vocalism with some dexterity in the execution of ornaments, but a language of expression, the grammar of its effects responsive to the setting of the words. [Michael Scott, in The Record of Singing]  His friendship and collaboration with the composer Sergei Rachmaninov was one of great importance for both of them - Rachmaninov coached Chaliapin in several roles, including Boris, and gave him an education he'd never had, in the history and styles of music. Chaliapin showed the composer something of the possibilities for the human voice, and as a result, Rachmaninov's songs are some of the most exquisite ever written.

So in order to convey to the audience what his character is thinking or feeling, whether on the opera stage or in the recital hall, Chaliapin might take liberties with the music - deliberately push a note sharp or vary the tempo - in order to gain dramatic intensity. Even though many of the Italian singing devices that were used for variations in the vocal line or for ornamenting the singing originated for that language (note they all have Italian names) Chaliapin managed to apply them to the cadence of the Russian language, so unlike Italian, in ways that few have ever been able to do. And some critics may have complained that he distorted music beyond recognition - but his expressive acting and his unique interpretation of the music connected Chaliapin to his audience in the personality of the character, and made him a collaborator with the composer of every piece he sang. Oda Slobodskaya wrote, "[H]ear him interpret four or five different songs, and you would think it was four or five different singers."

With the great gift of the voice, Chaliapin was fortunate to have learned the right techniques at the right time in his life to give him complete control over the voice, including messa di voce. Chaliapin had a range, power, flexibility and expressiveness to his voice that was unusual in his time, and remains so. He could spin out a fil de voix, a "thread of voice," to diminsh or swell the tone. This kind of control is exceptional, especially at the pianissimo level - and extremely unusual for the lower voices. Arthur Rubinstein said it had a "unique quality; powerful and caressing, soft as a baritone's and flexible as a tenor's, it sounded as natural as a speaking voice." Interesting to recall that his most influential teacher, Uzatov, had himself been a tenor.

Chaliapin gave an impression of both spontaneity and intensity in everything he sang - something that we not only hear little of in today's world, but something that was exceptional enough in his time to make him noted for far, far more than his towering stage presence.

"Chaliapin will never die; for with his fabulous talent this marvellous artist can never be forgotten... To future generations Chaliapin will become a legend."

- Sergei Rachmaninov

Feodor Chaliapin, 1913

Step back a hundred years and acquaint yourself with this remarkable artist by reading some of the accounts of Feodor Chaliapin's dynamic performances at the Met, below: the first two roles of his debut season in 1907, and his Boris Godunov in 1921.

 
 

NOVEMBER 20, 1907

Feodor Chaliapin makes his Metropolitan Opera debut in the title role of a new production of Boito's Mefistofele.

Feodor Chaliapin as Mephistophélès in "Faust"


DECEMBER 12, 1907

Three weeks later, Chaliapin appears in his second role - Basilio in Il Barbiere di Siviglia. The audiences loved him. However, few performances have divided critics more sharply... read on.

Chaliapin left New York at the end of that first season (which also included the Faust Méphistophélès and Leporello in Don Giovanni - a role he learned in a few days) and would not return for 14 years.


 

"He is an elemental creature, roaring and champing like a bull, charging the poor sinners of this world with the fuss and energy of a 60 horse-power motor and leaving a trail of fire and brimstone behind him. This is the Satan resulting from the union of the Italian creator and Russian interpreter.
Chaliapin as Mefistofele
"His frame, gigantic as it is, cannot contain his nature. He writhes with the emotions that convulse him. His face is drawn into expressions of the profoundest agony.... All the dramatic action tending to establish this conception of Boito's Satan is accompanied by every helpful aid of light, scenery and mechanical ingenuity. M. Chaliapin takes the utmost pains with his make-up, which combines effectively the use of fleshlings and bare skin. The skin is covered with shiny, metallic powder with sparkles in the calcium."

- W.J. Henderson, The New York Sun

 



"It cannot be said that his Basilio is on the same high artistic level, either vocally or dramatically, as Mr. Edward de Reszke's, which was one of the things to remember a lifetime. Mr. Chaliapin's conception of the part is much coarser. He forgets that a man with such manners would hardly have been engaged by a Dr. Bartolo to give music lessons to his Rosina."

- The New York Evening Post

"He makes an eccentric and grotesque character study of the part. Many of his doings and gestures are amusing; but it would be well for him to learn that some others of them are not acceptable to the real public of the Metropolitan Opera House."

- The New York Times

"He spared the audience nothing. He sang the 'Calumnia' aria quite as badly as he did at the first performance and was cheered to the echo by the gallery and the railbirds.... However, it was said many years ago 'De gustibus non est disputandum,' and later 'Chacun à son goût.' If that is the sort of thing Metropolitan Opera House audiences like they must be permitted to do so."

- W. J. Henderson, The New York Sun

 

"When Chaliapin plays Basilio the opera should be named for that part, as his hypnotic, impressive personality dominated every scene. Looking like an elongated Micawber in his snuffy, short-sleeved soutaine, this wonderful comedian, for such his impersonation last night proved him, swayed his audience at will. There was infinite spontaneous humor in every movement; every detail of gesture, by-play and make-up was inimitable; and oh, those wonderfully expressive hands! The song, 'La Calunnia' had to be repeated, so really marvellous was its interpretation."

- Reginald DeKoven, The New York World

  Feodor Chaliapin, as Basilio
 
Feodor Chaliapin as Basilio in "Barbiere" (at La Scala)   "The performance that was in open defiance of traditions, that was glaringly and recklessly unorthodox, that set at naught the accepted canons of good taste, but which justified itself by its overwhelming and all-conquering humor was the Basilio of Mr. Chaliapin. With his great natural stature increased by art to Brobdingnagian proportions, a face that had gazed on the vodka at its blackest, and a cassock that may be seen but not described, he presented a figure that might have been imagined by the English Swift or the French Rabelais. It was no voice or singing that made the audience redemand the 'Calumny Song.' It was the compelling drollery of those comedy hands.

"You may be assured, persuaded, convinced that you want your Rossini 'straight' or not at all. But when you see the Chaliapin Basilio you'll do as the rest do - roar. It is as sensational in its way as the Chaliapin Mephisto."

- The New York Globe

 


 

"Last night nobility of acting was paired with a beautiful nobility of voice and vocal style, and his Boris stood out of the dramatic picture like one of the old time heroes of tragedy.... He sang in Russian: and though it was possible even for those unfamiliar with the language to feel some of the intimacy which must exist between the original text and the music, the effect upon the Russians in the audience was akin to frenzy. All that we have heard of the greatness of his interpretation of the character of Boris was made plain. It was heart-breaking in its pathos, terrible in its vehemence and agony."

- Henry E. Krehbiel, New York Daily Tribune  1921

  chaliapin_24.jpg (9713 bytes)


 

XXX

 

TOP OF PAGE     |    RECORDINGS      |     METROPOLITAN OPERA REVIEWS      |    EXPLORE MORE
 
BOOKS
 
order CHALIAPIN CHALIAPIN - A Critical Biography   by Victor Borovsky

Author and tenor, Nigel Douglas, who shares a few things about singing and writing in MORE LEGENDARY VOICES, calls this the best biography of a singer ever - and he may just be right. Exhaustively researched, Borovsky focuses on Chaliapin the artist, quoting at length from press notices, letters and memoirs in this first-ever English-language biography of the singer. He also analyzes Chaliapin's own writings - and notes differences between the versions that appeared in Russia or in England and the United States, where he tones down
some of his comments. The author paints a picture of the unique talent and personality that made Feodor Chaliapin such an influential figure in the operatic world, bringing a real understanding to the forces at work in a highly creative person. Quite a few photographs; detailed discography by Alan Kelly. Highly recommended.
 
SOUND REVOLUTIONS   by Jerold Northrup Moore
Fascinating biography of F.W. (Fred) Gaisberg and his brother, the industry they helped create - and all the personalities they dealt with. Extensive quotes from diaries and letters; the photographs are fairly small, but very useful. Chaliapin is mentioned throughout, with stories about him recalled in the kind of detail that brings the artist and the man to life. There's a wonderful photograph of him with the Gaisberg brothers and two other men, dated 1913. Even without the top hat he's wearing, Chaliapin would tower over everyone else, dominating the image. His eldest daughter claimed he was not quite six foot two, and it was "merely" the force of his personality that made him seem larger than life... perhaps the other gentlemen in this photograph are all about five foot three! Lovely book. Highly recommended. order SOUND REVOLUTIONS
 
MAN AND MASK: 40 YEARS IN THE LIFE OF A SINGER   by Feodor Chaliapin

Borovsky notes that the title itself is a poor translation - he suggests Mask & Soul. The Russian word (dusha) loses something in the English translation of "soul"  - it has less to do with the strictly spiritual interpretation of the word and is far more personally integrated in the human being.

 
CHALIAPIN - AN AUTOBIGRAPHY
AS TOLD TO MAXIM GORKY

by James Hanley

Chaliapin and Gorky were inseparable for many years - kindred spirits - until a falling-out occurred. It had something to do wtih the publication of this book, though details are hard to piece together. Still a valuable reference, though you may want to consider it as one piece in the puzzle, rather than as absolute fact.

Gorky and Chaliapin - click here to order the autobiography
Gorky and Chaliapin

 

 
TOP OF PAGE     |     BOOKS     |    METROPOLITAN OPERA REVIEWS     |     EXPLORE MORE

 

SELECTED RECORDINGS FEATURING FEODOR CHALIAPIN

click on the picture to order the CD or video

 
order THE CHALIAPIN EDITION order FEODOR CHALIPIN ON STAGE order CHALIAPIN order A VOCAL PORTRAIT
THE CHALIAPIN EDITION

Arbiter Records is compiling every recording he ever made, with extensive notes & photos.
5 CD volumes (of 13) are already done. Amazing.

FEODOR CHALIAPIN ON STAGE

Faust, Mefistofele, Boris, Mozart and Salieri (by Rimsky-Korsakov)

PRIMA VOCE: CHALIAPIN

Classic arias from Faust, Mefistofele, Boris, more ... plus songs.

CHALIAPIN: A VOCAL PORTRAIT  - 2CDs

The Russian arias, Le Veau d'Or, and La calunnia. Acoustic and electric recordings.


order HIGHLIGHTS FROM BORIS GODOUNOV order ON THE WINGS OF BEL CANTO order COVENT GARDEN order A TREASURY OF OPERA
BORIS GODOUNOV
Modest Mussorgsky

highlights

ON THE WINGS OF BEL CANTO
40 Legendary Recordings 1905-49

Chaliapin sings from Norma

COVENT GARDEN - AN EARLY HISTORY ON RECORD

Volume I of IV

THE PRIMA VOCE TREASURY OF OPERA - VOL. 1

2-volume set consisting of 11 CDs total - massive historical record.



VIDEO / DVD

RUSSIAN OPERA AT
THE BOLSHOI
THE VINTAGE YEARS

order RUSSIAN OPERA AT THE BOLSHOI

"This tape is a compilation of lengthy scenes from films (most of them quite rare) and live performances. The singing has English subtitles. There is no narration and, apart from the brief Chaliapin sequence, there are no documentary scenes.

"Many of these singers are virtually unknown in the West yet had major careers. Most are vocal actors of great nuance. Lemeshev is a far more lyric and tender Gherman than those to whom we’ve become accustomed. He and Kozlovsky were long-time rivals; each sings Lensky’s aria, with quite different emphases. Krivchenia is a patter-buffo in the Italian tradition. Vishnevskaya is a delicate Lisa; caught early in her career, her voice is well-focused and in tune. Bass Maxim Mikhailov is the standout for me because of his variety of tonal shadings and deeply felt performance.

"These excerpts capture much of the emotional complexity of the Russian tradition. They contain some of the most interesting footage ever even if you’re not particularly drawn to Slavic opera."
- Stefan Zucker, for The Bel Canto Society

THE GREAT SINGERS OF RUSSIA  Vol. 1 - Chaliapin To Reizen

An epic video series hosted by soprano Ljuba Kazarnovskaya, featuring interviews with Ivan Petrov, Irina Arkhipova, and Joan Dornemann, and extensive performance segments: Vol. I includes performance segments by Feodor Chaliapin, Alexander Pirogov, Ivan Koslovsky (including a duet with Paul Robeson), Sergey Lemeshev, Pavel Lisitsian, Mark Reizen (including an operatic performance at age 90!), Maxim Mikhaliov, Natalja Shpiller, Georgy Nelepp.

chaliapin_dvd2.jpg (5823 bytes)

TOP OF PAGE     |    RECORDINGS      |      BOOKS    |    METROPOLITAN OPERA REVIEWS



MORE ABOUT FEODOR CHALIAPIN

 

Arbiter Records
home of the projected 13-volume compilation
of all Chaliapin recordings

Feodor Chaliapin - a great Russian bass

 

return to Words & Music Shop Main Page

return to Words & Music - Recommended Singers

questions/
comments
e-mail ML Hart
send e-mail

 

 


all reviews by ML Hart except as specifically noted
original content ©2005 ML Hart, graphics ©1999 ML Hart and images ©1999 ML Hart except CD covers or where noted

portrait of the younger Chaliapin (top of page) by Aimé Dupont, 1907, New York

Sandy Steiglitz keeps a website overflowing with singer photographs, many of them from the vintage era I so admire -
my thanks to her for all the work she does there

all reviews of Mefistofele and Il Barbiere di Siviglia were from The Metropolitan Opera website (History at the Met)
[that page has since been updated and is no longer available]
photograph as Don Basilio (second one, without the hat) at La Scala, 1933, by M. Camuzzi and Crimella, Milan
drawing of Chaliapin and Bonci, 1907, by Enrico Caruso

monetary conversion formula provided by Professor Robert Sahr of the
Oregon State University Political Science Department,
adusted by using an inflation calculator on the Columbia Journalism Review website
- see further discussion of how to convert currency of different years on the Caruso page -

the negative-reviews-at-the-Met item Borovsky refers to is from Carl Van Vechten, Interpreters and Interpretations

Rachmaninov quote from MORE LEGENDARY VOICES by Nigel Douglas, who brings singers to life, both
vocally and personality-wise, in his wonderful books

comments on Mefistofele (by Boito) and on Boris (on Chaliapin's appearance at the Metropolitan Opera
after an absence of 14 years) quoted in Michael Scott's
THE RECORD OF SINGING ...
...as with all these Artist Profile pages, I find myself immensely grateful for that massive two-volume work. It has helped me understand far more about singing than I ever believed I could. Jump to a brief review of the books on the Great Tenors of the Early 20th Century page, and if you're hooked on generations past, as I am, explore more for yourself.

description of the videotape RUSSIAN OPERA AT THE BOLSHOI by Stefan Zucker, from his Bel Canto Society website -
another favorite resource and shopping center


no part of this page, site, or any components may be borrowed, downloaded, acquired, or otherwise
used by any person(s) without the express written consent of ML Hart
- all rights reserved -


what is copyright all about?